Skip to content

Scamalytics Alternative: My IP Help vs Scamalytics

Compare IP fraud scoring: feature breadth, detection methods, free tools, and API pricing.

By Last updated: Nov 2, 2026

0:00
0:00

Scamalytics is a fraud-detection company that gives any IP address a fraud score from 0 to 100, built mostly from the traffic it sees across its clients’ websites. My IP Help is a free alternative that also scores an IP from 0 to 100, from public and licensed lists, and shows every reason and source behind the number.

My IP Help is our product, so read the comparison with that in mind. We read the Scamalytics pages cited here on 1 November 2026; prices are as of that date.

What is Scamalytics?

Scamalytics Ltd sells fraud detection at two levels. The first is the IP fraud check: a score per IP, available through a free web lookup, an API, a bulk upload and a downloadable MMDB database. The second scores users across many data points with shared blacklists and machine learning, aimed at dating services and social networks, which it says is “particularly effective against dating scammers and romance fraud”. Its home page lists clients in banking, payments, classifieds, reviews and dating.

Small hobby robot with an ultrasonic sensor and a camera on a wheeled chassis
Credit: JUNXUAN BAO via Unsplash

An IP result on Scamalytics shows the score and a risk label, a paragraph explaining it, the operator (hostname, ASN, ISP), a location from DB-IP, whether the address is in a datacenter, and a set of yes/no checks: VPN, Tor exit, server, public proxy, web proxy, search engine robot, residential proxy, and five external blacklists (FireHOL, IP2Proxy Lite, IPsum, Spamhaus and X4Bnet Spambot).

How is the Scamalytics fraud score calculated?

Scamalytics does not publish a formula. What its result pages say is that the score reflects how much potentially fraudulent web traffic it sees from that address, or from its operator, across its network, which it describes as having “visibility into many millions of internet users per month”.

When it has no direct view of an IP, it falls back on the operator’s overall risk. For 8.8.8.8 its result page says it has “no visibility into the web traffic directly from 8.8.8.8, and therefore apply a risk score of 0/100 based on the overall risk from Level 3’s IP addresses”.

Behaviour seen in real web traffic to its clients’ sites can catch a bad address before any public list does. But you cannot see which signals produced a given number, and the pages say the opinion covers only web connections to websites and apps, not server-to-server traffic.

What is a good or bad IP fraud score?

On both tools, lower is better and 0 is the lowest risk.

Scamalytics labels its scores with a risk level (“Low Risk” for 8.8.8.8); its own list of high-risk addresses on the IP check page shows many at 100. My IP Help uses three bands: Low 0–29, Medium 30–69, High 70–100. A score is a reason to look closer, not proof: a Medium IP is often a VPN user, and many people use VPNs for privacy. Neither score says anything about the person behind the address, only about the address.

How My IP Help scores an IP

Points add up, capped at 100, and every signal that adds points is listed with its source. The main weights:

SignalPointsSource
Tor exit node75Tor Project exit list
In a hijacked or criminal netblock70Spamhaus DROP (© The Spamhaus Project)
On public blocklists20 for one list, up to 60IPsum (aggregates 30+ lists)
On FireHOL’s attacker lists45 (level 1) or 30 (level 2)FireHOL
Public proxy45Public proxy lists
VPN service30VPN provider ranges
Datacenter or cloud15Published cloud and datacenter ranges
iCloud Private Relay5Apple’s relay ranges
Verified bot (Googlebot, Bingbot …)0The operator’s published ranges

So Google’s 8.8.8.8 scores Low on Scamalytics, and on ours a datacenter address with nothing else against it gets 15 points, also Low, while a Tor exit that is also on blocklists reaches High. Run any address through the IP lookup or the IP reputation check to see its score and reasons.

Feature comparison

Feature (as of November 2026)My IP HelpScamalytics
Score0–100, Low / Medium / High0–100 with a risk label
Built fromPublic and licensed lists, each named on the resultTraffic seen across its clients’ sites, plus proxy and blacklist data
Reasons shownEvery signal with its points and sourceYes/no checks and a text explanation; no breakdown of the number
Free web lookupYes, no signupYes
Free API tier1,000 lookups a month (score, location, network)5,000 lookups a month (score, geolocation, proxies, datacenter, ASN, blacklists)
Paid APIFrom $29/month for 100,000 lookups, with the reasonsFrom $25/month for 25,000; $100 for 100,000; premium data add-ons from $20/month
Bulk lookupPaste up to 100 IPs; first 5 free; reports from $1.99; each IP’s type and blocklist count (no 0–100 score)Upload CSV or TXT, enriched CSV out; counts against the API allowance
Self-hosted databaseNoYes (MMDB, flat fee)
Residential proxy detectionNo dedicated feedYes (premium add-on for details)
Network tools23 (DNS, WHOIS, ASN, ports, SSL, traceroute …)None

Key differences

Behaviour vs lists

Scamalytics’ main input is behaviour on its clients’ sites, which no public list has.

My IP Help has no network of client sites, so it does not claim to have seen an address misbehave; it reports what published lists and ranges say about it. If you need a signal from live fraud traffic, that is Scamalytics’ edge. If you need to justify a block to a customer or a colleague, a named reason (“Tor exit, listed on 3 blocklists”) is easier to defend than a number.

Price at volume

Scamalytics’ free tier is larger: 5,000 lookups a month against our 1,000. At 100,000 lookups a month Scamalytics charges $100 and our Pro plan $29, with the reasons included; Scamalytics publishes tiers up to 100 million a month, which we do not. Its premium proxy, geolocation, ISP and residential proxy data cost extra.

API score vs website score

Our API leaves out two of the lists the website uses: IPsum and FireHOL levels 1 and 2. Both include DShield data, whose terms do not allow use in an API for now, so an address can score lower through our API than in the website lookup.

Breadth

Scamalytics focuses on fraud scoring. My IP Help puts the risk check next to location, owner and a link to the abuse contact, and the admin’s toolbox: blacklist check, ASN lookup, DNS lookup, WHOIS, port checker and SSL check. For investigating one suspicious address end to end, that saves switching sites.

When to use each tool

Choose My IP Help when:

  • you want to see why an IP scored what it did, signal by signal
  • you are investigating an address and also need its owner, abuse contact or network tools
  • you want a list of up to 100 IPs checked at once, with each address’s type (such as VPN, proxy, Tor exit, datacenter or residential) and how many public blocklists name it

Choose Scamalytics when:

  • you want a score informed by fraud traffic seen on other sites
  • you need more than 1,000 free lookups a month, or a self-hosted MMDB
  • residential proxy detection matters to you
  • you run a dating or social platform and want user-level scam detection
Person typing with a bank card in hand at a laptop
Credit: Tima Miroshnichenko via Pexels

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Scamalytics?

A company that sells fraud detection, best known for its IP fraud score: a 0–100 rating of how risky an IP address’s web traffic looks, available as a free lookup, an API, bulk checks and a downloadable database.

How is the Scamalytics fraud score calculated?

Scamalytics does not publish the formula. Its result pages say the score reflects potentially fraudulent traffic it sees from an address, or from its operator, across its clients’ sites, and that it uses the operator’s overall risk when it has no direct view of the IP.

What is a good Scamalytics fraud score?

Lower is better: 0 is the lowest risk and 100 the highest. A low score means Scamalytics has seen little suspicious traffic from that address or its network, not that the address is proven safe.

Is Scamalytics free?

The web lookup is free, and its API and bulk lookup include a free tier of 5,000 lookups a month. Paid plans start at $25 a month for 25,000 lookups, with a free trial, as of November 2026.

Why is my IP fraud score high?

Usually because the address is a VPN, proxy, Tor exit or datacenter server, is on a blocklist, or belongs to a network with a lot of abuse. On My IP Help the IP lookup lists each reason; a shared mobile or VPN address can score high because of other people’s traffic.

Is there a free alternative to Scamalytics?

My IP Help scores any IP from 0 to 100 for free with no signup and shows the signals and sources behind it. Its API includes the score for free up to 1,000 lookups a month, and the IP reputation check scores one address at a time. The API score leaves out two of the lists the website uses (IPsum and FireHOL levels 1 and 2).

Does a high fraud score mean the person is a scammer?

No. Both tools rate the address, not the person. VPN users, travellers and people on shared mobile networks can all appear on risky addresses. Use the score to decide on extra checks, such as a captcha or verification, rather than as a verdict. The VPN and proxy detector shows whether a VPN is behind it.

Can I use both tools together?

Yes. Scamalytics adds a behavioural signal from its client network; My IP Help adds named list matches, owner details and network tools. Checking a flagged address in both gives you a score and the reasons to act on it.

Try it yourself

Check an address on our IP lookup, see whether it is a VPN with the VPN and proxy detector, or check a whole list with the bulk IP lookup. Developers can start with the IP risk API and the API docs.

Create your free account

Get access to IP lookup tools, bulk reports, and more. Free forever.